How much manual work costs your business and how to calculate it

Retyping data, compiling spreadsheets and keeping an eye on deadlines does not look like a big expense. Added up over a year, though, it often equals a full-time job. We will show you how to calculate it and when automation pays off.

Published
Reading time7 min
AuthorIng. Jaroslav Fikar

Most companies have work that nobody enjoys but everyone takes for granted. Someone retypes orders from e-mails into the system every morning, someone else compiles a report from several spreadsheets at the end of the month, another person phones customers about unpaid invoices. Each task takes only a few minutes. Together, though, they often add up to dozens of hours a month, and you will never see them as a separate line in your accounts.

In this article we will show you how to calculate the cost of manual work, which hidden costs come with it, and how to tell it is time to automate.

Why manual work stays invisible

Manual work is spread across the whole day and across several people. Nobody has "retyping data" in their job description; it is just a small part of their agenda. That is why companies underestimate it. It also grows gradually: every new customer, product or branch adds a little more copying and checking, until one day you realise you need another person just to keep up.

Typical tasks that can be automated:

  • retyping orders, enquiries or forms into an internal system,

  • issuing invoices by hand and checking who has paid,

  • compiling reports and overviews from several spreadsheets,

  • copying data between the online shop, the warehouse and accounting,

  • sending the same e-mails to customers or suppliers,

  • keeping track of deadlines, stock levels or contract expiry dates,

  • creating documents from templates, such as quotes, contracts or handover reports.

How to calculate the cost of manual work

You do not need a complex analysis. A simple calculation you can do in an afternoon is enough.

1. List the repetitive tasks

Go through with your colleagues what they do repeatedly every day, week and month. Focus on tasks where data is moved from one place to another or where someone checks that nothing is missing. It works best when people record for a week how much time they spend on each task. Estimates from memory tend to be far lower than reality.

2. Convert the time into hours per month

For each task, multiply how long it takes by how often it happens. If processing one order takes five minutes and thirty orders come in every day, that is two and a half hours a day, or roughly fifty hours a month.

3. Multiply by the hourly cost

Use the total cost of the employee, not just their net pay. That includes social and health insurance, benefits, equipment and a share of the company's overheads. The real cost of an hour of work tends to be much higher than the hourly wage. The result is what the task costs you every month. Multiply it by twelve and you will see the yearly cost, which is often surprising.

4. Add the cost of mistakes

Wherever people retype data, mistakes happen. A typo in an address means a returned parcel, a wrongly copied amount means an awkward call with a customer, a forgotten reminder means money that arrives a month late or not at all. Try to estimate how many mistakes you deal with each month and how much time and money it takes to fix them.

Hidden costs you will not see in the calculation

The numbers are only part of the story. Manual work also has costs that are hard to quantify but hold the company back just as much:

  • Slower response. A customer waits for an order confirmation or a quote because someone has to prepare it by hand. Meanwhile they may go to a competitor.

  • Dependence on specific people. When the person who knows all the spreadsheets and procedures is ill or leaves, the work stops.

  • Limited growth. If every new customer means more manual work, the company can only grow as fast as it can hire and train people.

  • Unhappy employees. Capable people do not want to copy data all day. Routine wears them out and keeps them from work that brings the company real value.

  • Decisions based on old data. When reports are compiled by hand once a month, you make decisions based on information that is already out of date.

Where artificial intelligence helps

Traditional automation handles data with a fixed structure well: an order from an online shop, a row in a spreadsheet or a payment on your account. But a lot of manual work happens where data has no structure. An order arrives as a free-form e-mail, a supplier's invoice as a PDF, an enquiry as a message from a contact form. This is where artificial intelligence helps today.

  • Reading documents and e-mails. AI extracts the details you need from free text or a PDF, such as the customer, items, amounts or dates, and passes them to your system.

  • Sorting and routing. It sorts incoming e-mails and enquiries by topic and urgency and sends them to the right person.

  • Drafting replies and documents. It prepares a draft reply to a customer, a quote or a summary that a person only checks and sends.

AI makes it possible to automate tasks that used to need a person simply because someone had to "read and understand" the text. Important decisions should still be checked by a person, though. You will find more in the article How artificial intelligence can help your business.

When automation pays off

Automation pays off where a task repeats often, runs the same way every time and works with data you already have in electronic form. Where human judgement, negotiation or creativity are needed, software will not replace people, but it can prepare the groundwork for them.

A simple rule: compare the yearly cost of the manual work (including mistakes) with the cost of the automation and of running it. If the investment pays for itself within one to two years, it is usually a good decision. For frequently repeated tasks it tends to be even faster, because the software saves time every single day.

Do not forget to think about what you will do with the time you save. The company can handle more orders with the same team, does not need to hire more people to grow, or can move employees to sales and customer care. Automation therefore often shows up in revenue, not just in costs.

Start with what hurts the most

You do not have to automate everything at once. The best results come from a step-by-step approach:

  1. Pick one or two tasks that take the most time or cause the most mistakes.

  2. Check whether an off-the-shelf solution is enough. Many tools you already use can connect to other systems or run automatic actions. Sometimes all it takes is setting them up and connecting them properly.

  3. Where off-the-shelf solutions fall short, consider custom automation. Typically this means connecting systems that do not normally talk to each other, or processes specific to your industry.

  4. Measure the result. After launch, compare the time and the number of mistakes with the original state. That gives you a basis for the next steps.

If you are considering a broader change, read our article Custom information system or off-the-shelf software? as well.

Summary

Manual work is one of the biggest hidden costs in any company. You do not see it on an invoice, but you pay for it every month in employees' time, in mistakes and in slower responses to customers. A simple calculation is enough to find out how much it costs you and to decide what to automate first.

If you are not sure where to start, we will be happy to go through your processes with you and calculate how much time automation would save. Get in touch.

Planning something similar?

Tell us about your project and we'll suggest a solution that makes sense.

Get a free consultation